Federal lawsuit over Confederate Flag ban being heard in East Tennessee

Save

Posted: 6:54 PM Aug 11, 2008
Last Updated: 11:13 AM Aug 12, 2008

96 comments

Poll

A | A | A

KNOXVILLE, Tenn. (WVLT) -- School systems across the nation will be watching as a federal jury in Knoxville decides if a ban on the confederate flag in Anderson County is acceptable, or if school officials crossed the line of free speech.

Should Tennessee students be allowed to wear Confederate flag patches and other clothing representing the "confederacy" to school?

Yes

Not sure

After 13 out-of-school suspensions for wearing clothing that had the confederate flag on it, Tommy DeFoe is continuing his fight over the right to wear the clothing, and this time a federal jury could make history with their decision.

Tommy DeFoe is out of school, but now he’s in court wearing a belt buckle with a Confederate flag like the one that got him suspended from a school in Anderson County.

A distant relative of a Confederate veteran, DeFoe is suing the school system, claiming it's his heritage and right to free speech while the school system says their ban is justified because it might offend someone.

After a jury was selected, attorneys put forth their opening statements. For the plaintiffs, attorney Van Irion told the jury "DeFoe's father taught him his history, but the school board decided it (the Confederate flag) is so bad it had to be banned from every school.”

Then school board attorney Arthur Knight addressed the jury telling them the "school is overwhelmingly white. If they have one black student, they have a duty to keep him safe."

The plaintiffs called four witnesses, including three school officials and a former student.

School board chairman Dr. John Burrell could not point to any racial incidents at the school that related to the flag, but said Oreo Cookies were once thrown at a basketball student of mixed race.

Irion asked if Oreo Cookies were banned from the school.

Burrell told the court that they weren’t.

Former student Ryan Miller told jurors he wore clothing with the Confederate Flag from Dixie Outfitters to school, but never had anyone complain.

Former principal Sidney Spiva referred to trying to look out for inappropriate clothing as "a constant battle."

This case could also be a first.

Southern Legal Resource Center attorney Kirk Lyons says many confederate flag cases are heard before judges and appellate courts but this may be the first, certainly in a generation, of one actually going to a jury.

Plaintiffs will resume their case Tuesday morning.

More Stories
Knoxville celebrates Independence Day

Former Vol Terry Moore killed in tree-cutting accident

Arson investigators look into Western Heights fire

Woman drowns in Douglas Lake, alcohol believed to be a factor

Police: McNair's death a homicide

UPDATE: Police investigate deadly shooting, high speed chase and crash

Flames engulf boat on Fort Loudoun Lake

Beefing up patrols on Tennessee highways

Comments are posted from viewers like you and do not always reflect the views of this station.

Posted by: Bruce Location: Western Canada on Jun 15, 2009 at 10:43 PM
I am a Canadian who is very much interested in Confederate history and I see nothing wrong with displaying the flag on one's clothing etc. I like to wear it in the form of a belt buckle just like Tommy Defoe does. However, I sure hope that young man keeps fighting his case and wins. I sure would if I was in his shoes. The Confederate flag to many, serves as a good symbolic measure indicating that one is tough, independent and can not be easy pushed around. And Tommy Defoe is living up to that. So all the best to him because he has my support 100%.

Posted by: IAN Location: WESTERN CANADA on May 4, 2009 at 03:54 PM
I am a Canadian and much fascinated by Confederate history. I am constantly researching the civil war and enjoy my hobby. Here in Canada there is also an uproar over the flag. I wear a Confederate flag belt buckle and display a large Confederate flag in my apartment which can be seen on the street. I have had many strange looks. However, as yet, no one has challenged me, but I do get rather odd looks. For the record, I notice that some belt buckle stores here are selling the Confederate flag belt buckle and they are becoming more in demand. I buy my buckles from Southern suppliers as they are better made and the Southern Cross of Honor is my favorite to wear. It is a classic. Keep on flying the flag folks, many of us support you.

Posted by: JR Location: Cleveland,Tenn on Jan 23, 2009 at 10:18 AM
How many of these people against the confederate flag are people from the north living and making their living in and on the South? they have culture classes when they go abroad as not to offend,why are our customs not important?

Posted by: mike Location: kansas on Nov 14, 2008 at 12:36 AM
my flags will fly intell the day i die the outlaw the flag you will have to kill me before they are lowerd

Posted by: Amelia Location: NC on Oct 23, 2008 at 09:12 PM
I feel the same as the two comments below! Kudos to the both of yall. :) I am doing my research paper on this whole controversy, and you both gave great ideas, so I thank both of yall! :) Thanks!

Posted by: Katy Ishee Location: Normandy TN on Oct 12, 2008 at 12:27 PM
I am ashamed of any govenrment that bans the Confederate flag..Bobama saidhe wouodn't wear the American pin (THAT pin) because some find it reminds them of oppression. Are we going to bury our American flag too and fly a new flag for Obama. If I was running around with the KKK onfront of my shirt lynching a black man,,,that's offensive. Seems to me a lot of people have forgotten, the Confederate flag is NOT the Klan and if they think it's offensive, they need a history lessons. My ancestors fought for the South and I'll be damned if I'm going to quit flying my Confederte flag because a minority find it offensive. The ones that do need a history lesson as they know nothing about it and how many people of different races that it does represent. When AMerica buries its hitory cuz of a few, that's Communism. Let the flag fly and learn your history. A sheet is the Klan's flag, not the Confederate Flag! Confederate flag will be flown 12th Annual Highway 41 Toy COnvooy Nov 2 Manchester,TN

Posted by: Becky Location: Texas on Sep 17, 2008 at 10:33 AM
Our high school here is known as the Rebels. The Rebel flag is part of that. It is only allowed to be used at our home stadium, but you will still people with on at away games. So far so good. Every now and then there has been a minor problem but for the most part if you don't like it there is always the other high school. It is part of the TN heritage so who has the right to take that away. We don't like many things though out our life time but we don't except everyone to change just because a few don't like it. Here's a thought - MOVE. People moved to the area knowing about it. If they didn't like it they shouldn't have moved there. Just like why should I have to learn spanish just to keep a job. If I moved to Mexico they wouldn't change the language to english just accomidated me. So you come here leagally or illegally you should adapt to the language here. In other words learn english.

Posted by: Charles Location: Blacksburg, VA on Sep 16, 2008 at 12:14 PM
If "offending someone" justifies a court case, or if one person offeds another there should be no court or "legal" action warrented to prevent such personal; feelings. Accept sometning or don't accept it...but don't take up time in court over such personal items. Be an American and work it out yourself!

Posted by: farrell dutton Location: alabama on Sep 15, 2008 at 08:50 AM
black men,white men,indians and hispanic, died in defence of dixie. i willnot disrespect any of their memory by claiming it is a white man's flag. it belongs to all southron people,all races.

Posted by: Carrie Location: Florida on Sep 15, 2008 at 01:27 AM
Those idiots! The CSA flags belong to the blacks as well as the whites - we had thousands of hero Black Confederates who proudly fought the north under the CSA flags ! - Tell the school board they need to learn somme REAL TRUE history for a change. Ban the USA Federal flag - that was the slave flag ! How can a school board be so ignorant and un-educated ? THEY need to be replaced ! After all this is OUR nation, not their's - go home Yankees ! STOP THE CONSTANT FEDERAL RECONSTRUCTION ! WE are not going to take it anymore ! Here - learn something ! http://home1.gte.net/carriet/TruthCivilWar.htm

Posted by: davin Location: knoxville on Sep 15, 2008 at 12:39 AM
why is this story...more than a month old...on this website. please!!!

Posted by: Reb Location: Mascot on Sep 14, 2008 at 09:56 PM
Steven..I believe the stars in the "bars" on the rebel flag is the southern states; NOT the original 13 colonies.

Posted by: joy87 Location: Anderson County TN on Sep 14, 2008 at 09:24 PM
OMG it is about time someone is standing up for our freedom of speech and our Heritage. And who says the confederate flag is something that goes toward Afican Americans...News flash it doesnt....!!! it just is a sign of our hertiage. There are African Americans wearing the confederate flag to this day.....So it should be aloud.

Posted by: tpsr1921@att.net Location: North Knoxville on Sep 14, 2008 at 04:40 PM
God Bless the Confederacy!!!!!!!!!!!

Posted by: Elaine Location: Florida on Sep 14, 2008 at 02:55 PM
Our Heritage is just that OUR HERITAGE and where does anyone have the right to take that away from our southern children...today there are so many black children wearing the Confederate t shirts because they for the first time ever are learning of their BLACK CONFEDERATE ANCESTORS...we are teaching all the truths of that war and finally it is being heard and these children are the ones who are researching. They are now learning that the majority of all southerners did live in peace and harmony.They are also learning of the right to claim their Heritage ...I know this to be so because I teach it to them. I am very proud of my Confederate Ancestors and I know why they fought and died for the dirt they owned here in North Florida...the very dirt we live on today. I say to all youths ...Stay strong ,be diligent and never ever give up...you are setting the path for the others to follow.

Posted by: Rick Location: Florida on Sep 14, 2008 at 11:13 AM
If a minority of Americans are offended by the "Stars and Stripes" will we ban it? This is "political correctness" taken to the ridiculous extreme. When I see the clothing that some students are ALLOWED to wear, pants down on their butts, etc. I wonder if our whole public school system is run on a "minority rule" basis. It doesn't affect my family as my son is in a fine private academy. I just feel sorry for those who MUST send their children to our dilapidated and capitulated public schools to recieve a 4th rate (lack of) education.

Posted by: Terry Location: ALABAMA on Sep 6, 2008 at 02:18 PM
I THINK PEOPLE SHOULD MIND THEIR ONW BUSINESS.

Posted by: Daniel Location: knoxville tn (karns) on Aug 22, 2008 at 09:31 PM
Tommy Defoe just wanted let you know that we got your back weither we are redneck or not.Me and my cousins are rebels and we have voted yes.It's heritage not hate,all the way.The schools could care less about what we like.Some people need to refresh our so called teachers principles,etc. that we are proud of the south and we could care less and if you don't like it,they need to go back to the north.The south rocks.It suppose to be a FREE AMERICA but obviously not.Me and my cousin are trying to get everybody that we can to vote yes.If they dont like our rebel flag they dont need to talk about it and they need to get it out of our history books if they want to play this game.It's funny how colored people can go around with there pant's hanging down and they are almost showing there self some time but we cant where something that we are proud of that kinda of sucks if you asked me.

Posted by: james Location: Virginia Beach on Aug 22, 2008 at 11:10 AM
So many people are offended by the sight of the Confederate flag. But you know what I find more offensive? Young "African Americans" walking around with their pants pulled down past their buttocks, exposing their boxers underwear. I think the NAACP needs to clean up their own first before throwing stones at Confederate flage supporters. Oh and another thing, that Hip Hop Rap music also offends me, degrading women. Again, our African American friends need to get there own house or crib in order before opposing the Confederate flag.

Posted by: joe Location: new jersey on Aug 21, 2008 at 02:56 PM
First of all ,the Confederate battle flag was not the official flag of the Confederacy but used in battle as the name implies,I think the new state flag of Georgia is similar to the official flag of the Confederacy. It seems to me that if people of skin color,particurally WHITE, want to express an interest in their southern culture or history then they become labeled racist but on the other hand I have my daughter come home from school and explain to me about how she learned about African history and even said the teacher told her the Confederate flag has no place in history! My word to the teacher was Confederate history is American history just because the naacp, big mouth al sharpton, and all of the Blacks have attained greater political power by banning the Confederate flag they just don't understand that this type of behavior will only lead to greater censorship in America! So I reccomend that all Americans of all nationalities wake up before its too late!!!

Posted by: Butch on Aug 18, 2008 at 08:51 AM
This is about rules in schools. There already are settled cases regarding limits to free speech within and during the school day. Outside of the bounds of the school, Tommie, or anyone else for that matter, can wear the confederate flag as a diaper if that's what makes their boat float.

Posted by: John Location: Birmingham, Alabama on Aug 17, 2008 at 01:18 PM
Wearing Conferate Patches on ones clothing is protected by the first amendment.

Posted by: Butch on Aug 16, 2008 at 02:43 PM
Missouri Compromise Controversy over whether Missouri should be admitted as a slave State, resulted in the Missouri Compromise of 1820, which specified that Louisiana Purchase territory north of latitude 36° 30', which described Missouri's southern boundary, would be organized as free states and territory south of that line would be reserved for organization as slave states. As part of that compromise, the admission of Maine as a free state was secured to balance Missouri's admission as a slave state.

Posted by: Butch on Aug 16, 2008 at 02:42 PM
The potential for political conflict over slavery at a federal level led politicians to be concerned about the balance of power in the U.S. Senate, where each State was represented by two Senators. With an equal number of slave states and free states, the United States Senate was equally divided. As the population of the free states began to outstrip the population of the slave states, leading to control of the House of Representatives by free states, the Senate became the preoccupation of slave state politicians interested in maintaining a Congressional veto over federal policy in regard to slavery. As a result of this preoccupation, slave states and free states were often admitted into the Union in pairs to maintain the existing Senate balance between slave and free.

Posted by: Butch on Aug 16, 2008 at 02:41 PM
Original status Prior to the American Revolution, all of the British North American colonies had slavery, but the Revolutionary War gave impetus to a general antislavery sentiment. The Northwest Territory, now known as the Midwest, was organized under the Northwest Ordinance with a prohibition on slavery in 1787. Massachusetts accepted that its 1780 Constitution effectively abolished slavery, and several other northern statutes required gradual emancipation. Conflict over new territories During the War of 1812, the British promised emancipation to slaves that would support their side. By the end of the War of 1812, the momentum for antislavery reform, state by state, appeared to run out of steam, with half of the states having already abolished slavery (Northeast), prohibited from the start [Midwest] or committed to eliminating slavery, and half committed to continuing the institution indefinitely (South).

Posted by: Jerry Location: McKinney, TX on Aug 16, 2008 at 08:49 AM
These people don't know the real reason for the Civil War. They think it was over slavery. Slavery wasn't the issue until President Lincoln brought it in to defeat the South. If everyone knew all the things about President Lincoln, the Lincoln Memorial would most likely be torn down.

Posted by: Clint Location: Fort Pierce, FL on Aug 16, 2008 at 06:01 AM
Dear misguided Butch, Do you like the present situation our nation is in? If not, don't blame the South. America lost when the South Was put on hold in 1865. You see Butch, our present situation is exactly what the South was fighting against.BTW, it took the industrialized, well equipped north four years to put down an army of rag tag Southerners. The difference Butch? Belief in what they were fighting for and heart Butch. Guts and heart. Something the material yankee will never understand. Another BTW, the South and General Stan Waite never surrendered butch. General Lee did.

Posted by: CptSnark on Aug 15, 2008 at 10:03 PM
Did anyone here notice that Tommyboy does not know which way is up on the Battle Flag? So much for pride in his heritage.

Posted by: Slim Location: Ithaca on Aug 15, 2008 at 09:59 PM
"...you Yankees just remember one thing, you invaded our homes. What kind of man would have stood around and not defend his family and home." Funny history you learned. Can we say Fort Sumter?

Posted by: Loy Location: Kingsport , Tn. on Aug 15, 2008 at 10:25 AM
Butch, yes the North won the Civil War by having unlimited supplies and man power, that does not make them legally right. Lincoln's primary objective was to save the Union not free the slaves. Well into the conflict he illegally turned the affair into black liberation as his secondary goal. The Emancipation Proclomation freed no one, Lincoln had no legal rights in the south and the document did not include the north. Another words, if you were in rebellion against him your slaves were free, if you were on his side your slaves were still in bondage.Lincoln was a racisit himself, he did not believe blacks should have the rights to marry whites, hold public office, or vote. He even had a plan to ship them all back to Africa. These things are a matter of public record but not taught in revisionist text books. Lincoln talked out of both sides of his mouth depending on the listener like all politicians. As for Gen. Lee, he did surrender but only after planting 300,000 yankees 6ft under.

Posted by: Charlene Location: Louisiana on Aug 15, 2008 at 02:45 AM
Proud to be from the South, so for all you Yankees just remember one thing, you invaded our homes. What kind of man would have stood around and not defend his family and home. Yes, I would be very happy to have my own country and get rid of those Yankee's who think they made us what we are today. When you get ready to leave our great country take your friends with you. Stay home up north, we don't bother you! I am very proud on my ancestors who fought, no one will take our pride that we share. Get over it!!!!!!!!!!!

Posted by: Joel Location: Charlotte on Aug 15, 2008 at 02:06 AM
the stupidest statement I have heard lately is, " If there is one black student at that school, then he must be protected." How in God's name does another student wearing a shirt honoring his Heritage threaten anyone? I pray someone points this out in court. Slavery is not an argument since it seems it's the blacks who are the ones that won't let the issue die.

Posted by: jimmy Location: kentucky on Aug 15, 2008 at 01:47 AM
Faye It is more than making a point. It is our right to fly the flag and we plan to exersize that right. We have been down trodden by yankee's and naacp and took it for far too long. Work has begun to raise another flag in KENTUCKY more to follow

Posted by: John Location: Fosters on Aug 15, 2008 at 12:51 AM
In the Declaration of Independace it states that if a government becomes tyranical it is your duty to change it by any means possible.Rawls law which was taught at the United States Military Accadamyprior to the war between the states as well as at ball law schools did in fact advocate the lawful secession of a state.That a state volentarily entered into the United States and could volentarily withdraw from the United States.The United States seceeded from England,then after forming the articles of Confederation had to seceede from them in order to form a Constitutional Republic (the United States of America),during the War of 1812 Danial Webster drew up secession papers for the New England states to seceede from the United States but with drew them when Andrew Jackson defeated the British in New Orlines.Perhaps we should return the United States to England and apologise to them for offending them with the secession during the American Revolution.The school board is offensive ban them.

Posted by: David Location: Alabama on Aug 14, 2008 at 10:37 PM
I have nothing but praise for Tommy DeFoe for standing up to the PC crowd, standing firm, standing tall and hanging in there for so long while this case makes its way through the legal system. It is not the 13 students who should have been expelled, it is the complainers and their supporters who should have been expelled and required to take some diversity training for their discriminatory practice of attacking anything Confederate by claiming it might offend someone. Bigots, I think, fits them nicely. And, as if Southerners are not offended by this practice. Public Schools sometimes seem to be more interested in social engineering than education. Southerners are propagandized, as in Anderson County, to feel guilty about their honorable heritage and symbols. Those who have studied the facts are not ashamed of their ancestors but we are ashamed of those who are. I am offended by the schools failure to educate and use the opportunity to explore the facts.

Posted by: Faye Location: Somewhere out there on Aug 14, 2008 at 02:22 PM
I believe this is just to make a point, the south want to wear their flags [which there are bumper stickers with confedrate flags on them stating "it was nice you visited ,Now go back where you came from"}and now theyre saying it's NOT HATE? What part about these bumpers stickers isnt hate towards Northerns? The south are hipacrits!!!!! They also want their own country, what will they do with all the yankee's that live there?......lol {which almost half of tenn is yankee's and if it werent for the yankee's , that place wouldnt be as well off as it is}.....lol

Posted by: Pam Pyles Location: Clinton on Aug 14, 2008 at 12:49 PM
My son went to Anderson County High School. He was also one of the young men that could not wear his Confedrate Flag shirts or anything to do with the flag. My son was a good student he just like to wear his shirts or what ever he had with the flag on them. There was one time that they put him in a hot pink t-shirt until I took him another shirt to the high school. I do not see anything wrong with what the young boys are wearing to school. There has been times that I have went to the high school and seen the young girls at the high school not dressed like they should be so why are they not sent home for not dressing right for school or why their mom or dad not have to bring them something better to wear at the high school? Thank god that my son is out of school.

Posted by: Daryl Location: Knoxville on Aug 14, 2008 at 12:42 PM
Absolutely people should be allowed to wear signs of the Confederacy! This is a part of HISTORY!! I feel the general public has been forced to endure TOO MUCH political correctness, and I for one am tired of it! Where is it going to stop? When people are in trouble for looking at someone wrong? Kinda sounds like a bunch of over grown babies, "Mommy he is looking at me! Mommy I dont like what he is wearing!!"

Posted by: Justin Location: Virginia on Aug 14, 2008 at 10:46 AM
James, from Corbin, KY, I do not beleive you are a retired history teacher. Kentucky was a Union state, like Missouri. Both did have small areas that supported the South, just like Tennessee had East Tennessee to support the North. Kentucky was by no means evenly divided. The only state that was so was Virginia. That's why we now have West Virginia, which I am still not sure how WV can be legally considered a state.

Posted by: Stefani R. Location: Knoxville, TN on Aug 13, 2008 at 11:19 PM
Yes you should be able to wear the confederate flag to school if a student wants too. It is apart of East Tennessee’s history. And for the record, the Civil War started because of SLAVERY, like all of the school books teach. The main reason for the start of the war is because of the UNFAIR TAXATION on the southern states cotton crops. So I do not see how the confederate flag has the potential brought up issues for racial slander toward African Americans. And by extension, if the confederate flag and it’s connection to the Civil War is so offensive to African Americans does this mean would should ban the teaching of the Civil War as well? The southern's who display the flag are PROUD of their history of their southern forefathers and what they fought for in the Civil War. Not because they are racist!

Posted by: Steve Location: Milton, TN on Aug 13, 2008 at 10:09 PM
Poor Butch, Poor, poor, cowardly Butch... I am so sorry that you need to use this forum to become Rambo. This is not about the "North" showing us what for again? It appears to me that our flag has continued to fly for the past 143 years following General Lee's surrender. Quite a feat for a defeated nation don't you think Butch? But, thanks to those like you, you keep that old so called Rebel blood a boiling and our resolve strengthens. Thank you Butch...and have a Dixie day!

Posted by: Steve Location: Milton, Tennessee on Aug 13, 2008 at 08:44 PM
This is why there is a problem with the flag. I belong to the SCV, I fly a flag in my yard and on my vehicle. Racist? NOPE! I love my black, brown, red, and yellow, brothers and sisters as much as white, and some more. Some of my confederate ancestors were from Ky and were mixed blood. BUT, they loved their homeland, the Confederacy. I think that our biases has stolen a great story from our children about their true history and the history of the great history of the southern United States prior to and following Lincoln. However; if they told the truth in that story, Mr. Lincoln would not appear to be the "savior" he has been portrayed as for the last 140 years. Y'all, let the kids wear the flag if they want! You tolerate sagging pants and this is an issue??

Posted by: Butch Location: far away now, thank you on Aug 13, 2008 at 08:34 PM
When will the rebels realize that the south LOST? Does the Union need to repeat the lesson? Even General Lee knew when to call it quits!

Posted by: Kearney Smith Location: Green Mountain, NC on Aug 13, 2008 at 08:31 PM
I'm offended that schools are falsifying history by not teaching the crimes commited against Southerners during the years 1861-65. The Confederacy was trying to separate itself from a hostile regime calling itself the United States government. That government was taking powers unto itself not granted by the US Constitution. That regime was doing then what the Soviet Union is doing today against its neighbor the State of Georgia.

Posted by: danny Location: knoxville on Aug 13, 2008 at 06:20 PM
I agree with Robert from Asheville “IF THE COURT BANS THE CONFEDERATE ITEMS THEN THEY MUST ALSO BAN ALL ITEMS S RELATED TO BLACK NATIONALISH, ITEMS RELATED TO THE BLACK GOVENORS CONFERENCE, BLACK MISS AMERICA CONTEST, THE NAACP, ETC, ETC OR ANY OTHER GROUPS ITEMS THAT MIGHT OFFEND SOMEONE. HURRAY FOR KIRK LYONS, A LEAST SOMEONE FIGHTING FOR SOUTHERN CITIZENS CIVIL RIGHTS. Also any other groups that have their own colors or style of clothes, this goes back to the school that is called the REBELS and now they can not have the confederate flag at their sport games.

Posted by: Butch Location: happy to be far away now on Aug 13, 2008 at 06:12 PM
Southerners and Cubs fans, both proud to be losers. it must be genetic

Posted by: audrey Location: greenback on Aug 13, 2008 at 06:08 PM
i would like to say, i think they should be able to wear the confederate flag to school, its NOT a symbol of racism, it supports the war, and our heritage!!!!! i think the children are there to learn, not get suspended for what they wear......what does that have to do with them learning, or their education, i think we need to focus on whats important, for example, if they get suspended from school, for what they wear, how are they learning? u shouldnt send them home, you should look into our history, and this includes all races

Posted by: Travis Location: Nashville on Aug 13, 2008 at 03:17 PM
Write School Board Chairman Dr. John Burrell and tell him how ludicrous his position is. That makes a difference.

Posted by: George H. Cooper Location: Asheville, NC on Aug 13, 2008 at 01:40 PM
I support any persons right to display any historical flag, including the Confederate Battle Flag, at any time or place (including clothing worn to school) as long as the person displaying the flag does not do so with the intent to disturb the "public peace". What could be wrong with that?

Posted by: JOHN Location: MSSISSIPPI on Aug 13, 2008 at 01:24 PM
THIS COUNTRY IS BECOMING MORE AND MORE SOCIALISTIC SUCH AS THE SOVIAT UNION USED TO BE. I DETEST BIG GOVERNMENT. THE CONFEDERATE STATES NEVER DID RE-JOIN THE UNION. SHOW ME THE DOCUMENT THAT SAYS {WE THE CITIZENS OF THE CONFEDERATE HAVE VOTED TO REQUEST TO REJOIN THE U. S. A.. TO MY KNOWLEDGE. MY G-G-GRANDPA WAS A CONFEDERATE CAVELRY LT. HE DIED A CONFEDERATE CITIZEN SO COMMING DOWN THE FAMILY TREE IS ME. THE ONLY CONFEDERATE MALE ON MY FATHERS SIDE OF OUR FAMILY.

Posted by: James Location: Corbin KY on Aug 13, 2008 at 01:23 PM
1000 strokes are not enough to address the remarks from some undereducated folks. The person who questioned Kentuckians right to be concerned - KY was a border state evenly split between Union and CSA. Comparing the battle flag to the Nazi flag is plain stupid. The states of the CSA had a right to seceed, as per the US Constitution. The battle flag was NOT the "National" flag - there were three different national flags. 40% of all regimental flags of the CSA bore Christian Crosses. The "X" on the battle flag is the Southern Cross, a Christian symbol. As one said, 95% of the CSA soldiers never owned a slave, most disapproved of slavery (which started in the North). The reason young people don't understand history is that they are not taught truth, texts contain info from liberal revisionists (I am a retired US History teacher.) The things our Southern ancestors feared have come true - High taxes, interference with religious practices, and regulated commerce. God save the USA.

Posted by: Jenny Location: Clinton, TN on Aug 13, 2008 at 12:48 PM
Are you politically correct or Historically stupid? That is one of my fave stickers... I also agree with the reader that asked if we were going to start banning crosses because the KKK decided to use them in their hatred crimes also.

Posted by: becca Location: sevierville, tn on Aug 13, 2008 at 11:38 AM
The kids should be able to wear the symbol of their heritage without any problems being created by their doing so. I, personally, encountered the same problem in my business when I had a contract to sell on a military base. I could not sell anything with the Confederate flag on it; neither could the servicemen (and women) wear these items on the base. Yet anyone who wished to sell (or wear) memorabilia with "Malcolm X" or "Martin Luther King"'s names on it were welcome to do so. African Americans have their history and Caucasians have theirs. Why can't we all live together without being so sensitive about such things?

Posted by: Ray Location: Weber City Va. on Aug 13, 2008 at 11:10 AM
I am a loyal member of the Sons of Confederate Veterans, meaning I had ancestors who fought proudly for the Confederacy. I also had three Uncles who fought in WWII, one even went in on the first wave of the D-Day invasion. My father served honorably during the Korean War, and I have a cousin currently on his third combat tour in Iraq. I extermely resent any "thick skull" on this site who has tried to link my family (deceased or living) to the likes of Racisism, Nazisim,Communisim,or Terrorisim. My family fought and is fighting with everything they have against tyrants such as Osama Bin Laden, Adolf Hitler, Tojo,Mao, or any other notorious war criminal. To ignorantly compare the Confederate battle flag to the Nazi Swastika is an insult not only to my family but all True Southerners alike. If any jerk who writes such trash wants to truly build a gallows beside the flag pole I'll gladly supply the lumber and rope.Providing they reserve it for total dullards like themsleves.

Posted by: Justin Location: Virginia on Aug 13, 2008 at 10:32 AM
This is very interesting. Many people that have made comments need a history leason (and an English one for that matter). First, why are people from Kentucky upset? Kentucky was a Union state, not a Confederate one. As for Tennesse, it was the last state to join the CSA and the first state to reunite with the Union. As for the area this is all taking place in, East Tennessee was very supportive of the Union, not the South. Second, as for the Confederate flag, the one in mention is a battle flag, nothing else. It never flew as the national flag of the CSA. Finally, as for one person saying the CSA were traitors, I asked that person to please read the History books a little closer.

Posted by: ROBERT Location: ASHEVILLE on Aug 13, 2008 at 06:58 AM
FREE SPEECH FOR THE STUDENTS OR ANYONE THAT WANTS TO WEAR THE CONFEDERATE CLOTHING. THE UNION FOUGHT THE WAR TO KEEP THE SOUTH IN THE UNION. EVEN LINCOLN SAID THE SOUTH COULD KEEP SLAVES IF THEY WOULD STAY IN THE UNION. SLAVERY WAS LEGAL BUT MORALLY WRONG. IF THE COURT BANS THE CONFEDERATE ITEMS THEN THEY MUST ALSO BAN ALL ITEMS SRELATED TO BLACK NATIONALISH, ITEMS RELATED TO THE BLACK GOVENORS CONFERENCE, BLACK MISS AMERICA CONTEST, THE NAACP, ETC, ETC OR ANY OTHER GROUPS ITEMS THAT MIGHT OFFEND SOMEONE. HURRAY FOR KIRK LYONS, A LEAST SOMEONE FIGHTING FOR SOUTHERN CITIZENS CIVIL RIGHTS.

Posted by: chris on Aug 13, 2008 at 06:13 AM
The schools have the right to have rules on dress,speech,activities,etc. of the children in their care. There should be a rule on no emblems,no printed messages, no pictures on clothing. The recent addition to a couple of schools in the county to require certain articles of dress would halt any perceived slam to anyone. On their off time they can express themselves all they want in what they choose to wear. By the way, I'm offended by the slovenly way many in society dress. But, then I'm a grandmother and everyone knows grandmothers like clean, neat kids. We are forever saying pull your pants up, push the hair out of your eyes, wash your hands, don't put that in your mouth, don't fight with your sisters/brothers etc.

Posted by: Pamela Location: Maryville on Aug 13, 2008 at 02:49 AM
Allow me to pose a question to those that the confederate flag offends: Do you pledge your allegience to the American flag? Most likely, you answered yes. The American flag flew over slavery for 85 years, from the time our country was founded in 1776 until the Civil War began in 1861. This is the same flag you pledge allegience to still today. The Confederate flag flew over slavery for four years, the years the Civil War was fought, between 1861 and 1865. However, slavery was not even the issue for the Civil War to begin with. Lincoln even stated in his inaugural speech that "he had no plans to end slavery in those states where it already existed, but he also said he would not accept secession." His idea was to keep the country together; it had nothing to do with slavery. Slavery was not an issue until very late in the war; it's funny how that seems to be left out of most people's versions of the Civil War. Most southerners view the Confederate flag as a way of expressing their rights, not a reference to slavery. These issues usually arise when someone wants better treatment, not equal treatment, and the actual historical events are twisted to suit one's own ideals.

Posted by: Carrie Location: Florida on Aug 13, 2008 at 02:22 AM
Do notice that this is a FEDERAL court and law suit ! Typical of the constant attacks the north has been doing on the south ever since 1861 ! They never stop ! The Federalist reconstruction still being FORCED on the CSA and our people ! They just can never leave us alone ! The CSA is still OUR nation and has been sicne the time of the colonies ! The Yankee North Federalists just cannot stop being the dictator over all the nations they have invaded and occupied - all illegally and Un-Constitutionally, but then the north shreaded the Constitution and true justice long ago!The south still holds to the Constitution of our Founders and freedom just as they fought for in the Lincoln war! The black people have just as much right to the Confederate CSA flags as the whites do - we had over 100,000 brave Confederate blacks proudly fight under those flags! ONLY ONE American flag ever flew over slavery and ALL the slave ships and racism = The USA Federal Flag! THAT is the flag that needs banning !

Posted by: Carrie Location: Florida on Aug 13, 2008 at 02:08 AM
Do notice that this is a FEDERAL court and law suit ! Typical of the constant attacks the north has been doing on the south ever since 1861 ! They never stop ! The Federalist reconstruction still being FORCED on the CSA and our people ! They just can never leave us alone ! The CSA is still OUR nation and has been sicne the time of the colonies ! The Yankee North Federalists just cannot stop being the dictator over all the nations they have invaded and occupied - all illegally and Un-Constitutionally, but then the north shreaded the Constitution and true justice long ago!The south still holds to the Constitution of our Founders and freedom just as they fought for in the Lincoln war! The black people have just as much right to the Confederate CSA flags as the whites do - we had over 100,000 brave Confederate blacks proudly fought under those flags! ONLY ONE American flag ever flew over slavery and ALL the slave ships and racism = The USA Federal Flag! THAT is the flag that needs banning!

Posted by: Jen Location: Clinton on Aug 13, 2008 at 01:24 AM
If you ban one thing that someone MIGHT find offensive, then you would have to ban EVERYTHING that ANYONE MIGHT find offensive. Next thing ya know, nothing is being taught and nothing is being learned. Why dont we concentrate on more important things in school besides clothes.

Posted by: Sandra Location: Briceville, TN on Aug 13, 2008 at 12:53 AM
Mr. Greg Deal is a liar. I am a former student of Anderson County High School, and i was still in school when hurricaine Katrina students showed up at the school and mayny students, including me, wore confederate flag t-shirts years before the students showed up. I dont see what the big deal is about the flag. It doesnt stand for racism, it stands for heritage. The people of the US fly and wear the American flag so whats the difference in flying or wearing the confederate flag? A flag is a flag no matter what is on it.

Posted by: Matthew Location: Tennessee on Aug 13, 2008 at 12:30 AM
People should realize that it doesn't violate anything because it's "hate speach." Not that any minority could feel comfortable at AC long enough to stick around: check the books, African Americans hardly exist at AC. It doesn't matter if it's heritage or not, it's ignorance. If you wear anything Confederate oriented then you're associated with racism, which is pathetic. Whether it's honoring a lost loved one or not, it's still honoring what they stood for: RACISM. It is offensive to ME and I'm Caucasian. Apparently one of the few left in AC with any intelligence or self-respect. Hitler was an intelligent man by all standards; should I be wearing a swastika to school? The only reason this is even an issue is because it's the south, which is an area known to be commonly racist. If the court rules that this is a violation of free speech then it might as well build a gallows right next to the flag pole. And, yes: it is a part of history--a part for which we should be greatly ashamed.

Posted by: RyanShawn Location: Bristol on Aug 12, 2008 at 11:47 PM
We are Confederate reenactors. The modern society associates the southern battle flag with racism. This makes no sense whatsoever. The war was not over slavery. The industrial north was controlling the country and the south was left out. They had constitutional rights to secede. Slavery was not a main issue. It is about heritage, not hate. I thought I would explain this, as many people these days are taught differently and do not understand. We are high school students who know THIS.

Posted by: dave Location: nashville, tn on Aug 12, 2008 at 11:41 PM
HERITAGE NOT HATE...THE LINCOLN-MARXIST MINDSET CONTINUES!!! H.K. EDGERTON (FORMER NAACP AND NOW SOUTHERN ACTIVIST) OF ASHEVILLE, N.C., WHERE ARE YOU?? DEO VINDICE AND GOD BLESS THE SOUTHERN NATION AND CAUSE. GEN. CLEBURNE'S QUOTE 146 YRS AGO WAS SO TRUE OF THINGS SUCH AS THIS IN SCHOOLS OF THE SOUTH. LOOK IT UP! IT'S HAUNTING! GOOD LUCK!

Posted by: fred Location: virgina on Aug 12, 2008 at 09:47 PM
if it's a free country you should be able to do what you want too. and those who don't like it can leave. go some place else to complain,

Posted by: tabitha bullock Location: clinton tn on Aug 12, 2008 at 09:19 PM
well i think it was stupid that he got kicked out of school for wearing the confederate flag cause i have tried to wear clothing with the confederate flag and was told to turn it wrong side out or call home for another shirt from my parents i think we should not be deprived of our heritage. we are all southeren born and bred and we should be able to show our pride good luck to the defoes on their case hope they win it for all the ones who want to wear the confederate flag

Posted by: The Students from ACS Bus #48 Location: Briceville, TN on Aug 12, 2008 at 08:08 PM
Most of us were graduates from the 2006 class of ACHS. We wore "dixie outfitter" t-shirts from the first day of our freshman year, until our last day of school our senior years. NOBODY ever started wearing those shirts just because an african american student came. We had african american officials in the school all the time, but it was no big deal. We all think all this stink is over nothing. By far, its not hate! Several of us were suspended for wearing those shirts. It didnt hurt anyone did it??? Not one person.

Posted by: Purliemae Location: Los Angeles on Aug 12, 2008 at 07:56 PM
These are the best comments I have ever read on a subject. Americans sticking together and fighting for something they believe in, something our ancestors fought for. Get rid of that school board first off. Let them hear your voices! Fight for the right .... figh for OUR flag!! God Bless you all!

Posted by: Harley Location: Wilmington, NC on Aug 12, 2008 at 07:40 PM
The confederate flag is just to honor our ancestors who fought to save original American Standards, Low Tax, Small Govt, States rights The flag is not racist.

Posted by: logan Location: knoxville on Aug 12, 2008 at 07:12 PM
All these comments claim the confederate flag is historic. This is true. It is the BATTLE emblem of the largest group of armed insurrectionists in our history! The Confederacy was a organization of traitors to the United States who took up arms against our government, and in so doing caused more American deaths than Ben Laden, Hitler and Mao Tse Tung combined. Shall we also allow our school children to wear swastikas? Red Army Stars? Shall we proudly display pictures of Ben Laden in our schools along side the pictures of the founding fathers?

Posted by: Gary Location: Williamsburg,Ky 40769 on Aug 12, 2008 at 07:04 PM
I believe that the students should be able to wear the conferdate flag to school or any where they would like. Just because someone wears the flag doesn't mean that it's out of hate! Alot of poeple that wear the flag means that its out of heritage. Alot of the people screaming hate doesn't even know what the flag is about.

Posted by: Jimmy D. Reed Location: kentucky on Aug 12, 2008 at 06:46 PM
"If they have one black student, they have a duty to keep him safe." This is the most dispicable statement I have seen for a long time. Are we White Southerner's expected to give up everything just some people say they are offended? This pc junk has gotten old already. We had a similar fight here in Ky. when a bunch of lying yankee's tried to make a school remove their Battle Flag and Confederate mascot. My Black friend's were on my side, as a SCV member that is. But it didn't go the way the yank's had planed and the liar's were exposed for the liar's they were and are. The school fought back and they still have their Flag and Mascot.Keep 'er flyin' boy's we are with you from all over the Country. Thank the LORD for Kirk and many other SCV men that will help you through you're fight. That's what it is, a fight it is a never ending battle that has carried over from our Ancestor's. To all concerned, you will find all true Southerner's a worthy opponent whether in Tennessee or whereve

Posted by: Ronnie Slack Location: Harriman on Aug 12, 2008 at 06:27 PM
My Confederate ancestors did not own slaves and were opposed to the institution of slavery. However, they were also opposed to the federal government becoming all powerful and overbearing which was in opposition to what our Founding Fathers envisioned. The Federal government originally was supposed to have limited and defined powers. My Confederate ancestors certainly did not go through four years of hell, fighting valiantly against overwhelming odds just to help the rich boys to keep their slaves. To say that the Confederate flag should not be displayed because someone might be offended because of past injustices would also mean that the U.S. flag should never be displayed. Native Americans suffered terrible injustices and atrocities under the U.S. flag and could justifiably be offended by it. Both flags represented some good things as well as some things that we may be ashamed of today. By the way, it was the U.S. flag that flew over the slave ships. The Confederate flag never did.

Posted by: Marie Location: Knoxville on Aug 12, 2008 at 06:23 PM
Malcolm X urged black people to separate from whites and win their freedom "by any means necessary." Have schools banned Malcolm X shirts or anything with an X on it for fear that it symbolizes Malcolm X? Che Guevara made derogatory statements about blacks and Mexicans... do you ban those colorful pop art t-shirts with his face on them? The clothing line FUBU stands for "For Us, By Us" and was started by black men. Isn't that racist? Do school districts ban FUBU clothing? The Confederate flag is no more incindiary than Malcolm X t-shirts. To each his own opinion as to what it means. I'm an Hispanic American and believe the flag is an historical item -- if blacks don't associate with it, so what? I don't know too many whites or Hispanics who relate to Malcolm X, but I do know many who are insulted by him and feel he was a racist.

Posted by: justin Location: tn on Aug 12, 2008 at 06:16 PM
No body has said any thing about the CONFEDERATE flag so why would the students or teachers start now. I'm not goning to stop wearing the confederate flag just because some people got there history twisted. And I hope that country boy don't stop either. thanks folk

Posted by: SAMUEL Location: VA. on Aug 12, 2008 at 06:10 PM
I Think They Should Wear the Patch Of The Flag Their Ancestor Fought For !!!!!!!!!

Posted by: Robert Location: Kingsport Tn. on Aug 12, 2008 at 05:41 PM
I wonder who is sitting on the Anderson County School Board? The 3 Stooges, Bozo the Clown , Goofy, Dumb & Dumber, Sponge Bob and his idiot sidekick Patrick, or worse. True the Confederate flag has been flown at KKK rallies for years but so has the "Stars & Stripes" and the Christian banner. I suppose those flags should be banned too. No slaves were brought to America under the Confederate flag which only flew for four short years. They were brought here on ships under "Old Glory" which has now flown for 232 years. If a flag is to be banned looks like the "Star Spangled Banner" is a much more guilty target for this board of morons to pick on. Of course to learn the truth about any flag one would have to pick up an unbiased text book and read it. It's obvious the Anderson County School board has never studied the "Southern Cross" beyond reading propoganda flyers issued by the NAACP. If the Confederate flag can be banned... whats next?... FREEDOM of SPEACH?

Posted by: Lady Val Location: Long Island, New York on Aug 12, 2008 at 02:01 PM
Whom do school districts fear offending when they impose these moronic rules? Certainly not conservatives or traditional Christians or Southrons or whites! No, though it may not be said, all know that it is the "favored minorities" - racial, ethnic or "sexual". Political correctness is what drives the culture today and it's restrictions must be enforced even if there is absolutely NO evidence that most "minorities" will be or are "offended". One complaint is enough to cancel the First Amendment! Founding Father John Adams said, "Be not intimidated... nor suffer yourselves to be wheedled out of your liberties by any pretense of politeness, delicacy, or decency. These, as they are often used, are but three different names for hypocrisy, chicanery and cowardice." That is the best definition of "political correctness" I ever heard. Save the First Amendment! Fly - and wear - the Battle Flag!

Posted by: Michelle Location: Elkhorn City, KY on Aug 12, 2008 at 01:40 PM
Young men and women, remember, always remember your heritage and keep the Battle Flag flyin! Mine is displayed proudly on my front porch in memory of my GGG Grandfather and my husbands' ancestors. God Bless.

Posted by: JW Location: Kentucky on Aug 12, 2008 at 01:19 PM
If the "Southern Cross" is ban then so should the X for Malcolm X tee-shirt. If the Battle Flag is ban then ban the African Colors on hats and other clothing. When will you ban the Cross or Star of David or Islamic Crescent because it offends Hindus or Buddaists

Posted by: Don Reagan Location: Dandridge on Aug 12, 2008 at 01:01 PM
The Confederate flag has nothing to do with black Hatred. It is representing states rights which no longer exist. Why do white people not have the right to show a flag that represents American History.As a Proud Grandson of a Yankee veteran who supports states rights I want the Government to take care of National problems and leave the small stuff to the citizens. The Confederate flag is a representation ofthe right of Tennessee to remember our ancestors sacrifice for their way of life. Slavery had nothing to do with the Civil war. IT was about the states rights to leave the Union. The North was against having the competion in commerce from a country that never had frozen harbors and a better place for commerce in general. Lincoln violated every law to quell the rebellion.

Posted by: Wade Location: Jefferson City, TN on Aug 12, 2008 at 12:17 PM
As Dixie Outfitters says, "If this flag offends you, you need a history lesson!"

Posted by: Ginnie Location: Durham, NC on Aug 12, 2008 at 11:31 AM
Why is it that every foreigner in the U.S. can claim their heritage except white southrons? Why are illegal Mexicans allowed to fly their flags? This is my heritage, my great grandparents, my history and I want to preserve it. I think that instead of constantly battling the conferderate flag as a symbol of hate that our tax dollars should be spent on teaching history - true history. The conferate flag was about states' rights - not slavery. Get an education.

Posted by: Scott Location: Florida on Aug 12, 2008 at 11:14 AM
If this Tennessee jury upholds a ban on Confederate symbols in Dixie, I'm going to puke! I'm writing donation checks to the Sons of Confederate Veterans (SCV) and Southern Legal Resource Center (SLRC) right now.

Posted by: Jerry Burton Location: Dandridge on Aug 12, 2008 at 10:34 AM
If it isn't a gang related symbol then it should be allowed. The article states that it might offend someone. If it does so be it. Sheesh, My John Deere Belt buckle or patch may offend someone as well. I'm so tired of the lack of backbone amoung the leaders of our society.

Posted by: John Location: Jefferson City on Aug 12, 2008 at 10:18 AM
Just because some ignorant, inbred rednecks in the KKK started using the Confederate flag as a sign of hate does not mean it is offensive. They do the same exact thing with the Cross! Besides, if one wants to get technical about the issue, people where enslaved by the U.S. flag before the Confederate one, and before that, by the British and French flags. Growing up in the South, I have many Black friends, none of them seem to be offened by the Confederate flag. I am aware of some who even wave it! It is heritage. There were even many Blacks who fought for the South during the Civil War. Some Blacks were even slave owners. I am not saying hate is alright to hold and practice, IT'S NOT! But the Confederate flag, to sound cliche, is not hate, it's heritage. In my opinion, the white, northern politicians need to leave the South! And anyone else from the North for that matter. Besides, there are far too many more important issues at hand other than fighting over a useless flag.

Posted by: Len Location: Hamblen Co. on Aug 12, 2008 at 09:47 AM
I think the Confederate Flag is a part of American History and it should not be band. We need to teach our children that is History and not a racial thing. It should be treated as such (a part of History).

Posted by: CSAcitizen Location: Florida on Aug 12, 2008 at 12:42 AM
Some one needs to tell all those Tenn folk that the Confederate flags also belong to the black folks just as much as they do to the whites. The blacks also fought proudly under the CSA flags - that NEVER stood for slavery or race ! The CSA Flags are Christian flags besides. Only ONE American flag stood for slavery and racism and flew over ALL the slave ships = the USA Federal flag ! The CSA FORBADE their flags fly over anything to do with race or slavery ! And the CSA flags never did. But the USA Federal Flag flies over all slavery, illegal invasions, occupations to this day just as it did in 1861 ! http://TripDownTruthRoad.com in the history section > Get the real true history for a change! You will never get it in the Federal schools or in any public forum!

Posted by: Paul Location: Maryland on Aug 11, 2008 at 11:22 PM
It might offend someone. The American flag might offend someone are we going to stop flying it ? It is just a piece of cloth. He should be able to wear what he wants.This is theUSA

Posted by: elizabeth Location: kodak tn. on Aug 11, 2008 at 10:00 PM
yes we should be able to wear clothes that reflect our history after all the other races wear whatever they please and dont consult us about it anyway the old saying goes when in rome do as the romans and if you dont like it go home right? we are rebels and we have rights to dont we?

Posted by: servant316 Location: Knoxville on Aug 11, 2008 at 08:09 PM
This thing concerning the conferate flag is foolish!Just because someone is wearing clothing like this,doesn't mean someone is racist.What about Christian's who wear Christian clothing? You going to ban them from their clothing because someone is "offended"? There is going to be people offended over one thing over another.Its foolish to ban something because someone "doesn't like what is said,or is offended". Now,if someone were encouraging others by their clothing to do something morally wrong,then that's another issue,but because someone is offended over these comaflage clothing,then your going to be banning alot of people that do wear these ,because they like them,not because of some racism.Racism is in the heart of a man/woman not from their clothing.

Posted by: James E Dyer Location: Knoxville Tn on Aug 11, 2008 at 07:40 PM
Right or wrong the Rebel Flag is a part of history and we can not change history. Slavery is a part of history and that was wrong!!!!

Posted by: Dr. Tim Location: Union County on Aug 11, 2008 at 07:34 PM
I am ashamed at the ignorance of the public school system that would advocate the punishment of a student wearing a confederate flag on his person. It is an outrage that the schools fail to teach the truth about our heritage. The fact of the matter is that the battle flag shown is only one of many flags used during the war. They have failed to teach their students the fact that many blacks fought for their South wearing the Grey uniform. They have failed in teaching States Rights as the foundation of the argument to which we fought. These very rights that are being taken away from us daily. I have ancestors that fought on both sides during this conflict and am proud of them all, as I hope my children will someday be proud of me for serving in the US Army as an officer, but I fought for the freedom of speech and the freedom of expression and for the ability for our public to know its history, to teach it, and to learn from it! Yes sir, let him wear it prouldly by God!!!! Dr. Williams

Posted by: Ivan Location: Maryville on Aug 11, 2008 at 07:27 PM
I'm 66 years old and we've gone in my lifetime from viewing the rebel flag as a symbol of the war between the states to it being a symbol of racism and hatred. If we can't wear clothing with the flag on it to school now, I believe we should irradicate all symbols and all references in any way to the War Between The States. We should get rid of the cemeteries and national monuments like Gettysburg and Chickamauga and any other historical sites concerning the Civil War. If having "free speech" means we can burn the American flag, I believe we should be allowed to have "free speech" and wear the Rebel flag. And our "free speech" can be whatever interpretation we want. We are now being told that we can interpret the Rebel flag in only ONE WAY. It is time we OBJECTED to politicans taking away our RIGHTS and its time we insist to the Black community that we have a right to our interpretation on the symbol of the flag--to some of us, one of being a rebel to a cause.

Posted by: david Location: dandridge on Aug 11, 2008 at 07:22 PM
Yes the kids should wear the rebel flag or belt buckle. First it is the school nickname, also a part of history are you going to take the parts of history out every time you do not like something? Wear it with pride

Posted by: steven brooks Location: sevierville on Aug 11, 2008 at 07:19 PM
THE CONFEDRATE FLAG STANDS FOR THE ORIGINAL THIRTEEN STATES OF THIS COUNTRY NOT FOR HATE OR RACIST. SOO AMERICA NEEDS TO READ THIER HISTORY BOOK AGAIN***

Posted by: Cilla Location: Newport on Aug 11, 2008 at 07:18 PM
Yes I think that student shoud be allowed

Currently	Local Radar

Weather Center \| Interactive Map \| Forecast

	Desktop Alert			VolTV2Go.com
	Add Us			E-Alerts
	Text Message			Contact Us
	Twitter			Widgets
	Facebook

Powered: Local.com