Immigrant Says Blount Judge Told Her To "Go Home" to Nicaragua
Save Email Print
Updated: 6:31 PM Dec 4, 2007
Immigrant Says Blount Judge Told Her To "Go Home" to Nicaragua
A Blount County woman says she turned to the court system for protection. Instead, she says she left feeling shocked, devastated and in tears. All because of what she says the judge said to her.
Posted: 5:05 PM Sep 12, 2007
Reporter: Jim Freeman
Email Address: jim.freeman@wvlt-tv.com
Font Size:

Maryville (WVLT) A Blount County woman says she turned to the court system for protection.

Instead, she says she left feeling shocked, devastated and in tears.

All because of what she says the judge said to her.

Volunteer TV's Jim Freeman has the rest of the story.

Anna Calixto's an immigrant, in the US legally.

She went to court last Friday seeking an order of protection from her estranged husband.

But, she says the judge told her to just "go home", back to nicaragua.

"He tells me you go back to your country. My husband, you go back to your country," Calixto says.

Anna says that's what Blount County Judge W. Dale Young told her last Friday in his courtroom.

It made front page news in today's Daily Times and it's been the buzz around Maryville.

Anna says, "Why go back to my country? I have two children here. He said. 'It's OK.' He says. 'I don't care.'"

Anna says she was in court about an order of protection against her estranged husband whom she says has been harassing her, calling her, and often showing up at her home trying to get visitation with their two children.

According to Young's office, there is no transcript, recording or documentation of what was said during Anna's hearing.

Kenneth Patterson lives in Maryville and read today's newspaper story and says, "I think that it was wrong in the first place for them not to have a reporter in the courtroom, because without a document of what's said, there's no proof about what's going on."

Lisa Barber with Tennessee Immigrant and Refugee Rights Coalition says, "It's a shame the community, documented or undocumented, that when they go in front of a judge that their rights to a court are abused. Instead of getting protection, they're told to go back to their country regardless of their status."

Judge Young gave us this statement, "By law, I am not permitted to discuss a case that is still pending."

Katie Monday lives in Maryville and says, "I would feel devastated you know if you can't turn to our court system, who do you have to turn to?"

Anna says, "This is horrible for me. It's no good. I need help for my children."


Latest Comments

Posted by: Pay Taxes and White Location: Tennessee on Sep 28, 2007 at 05:07 PM

The woman said her and her husband left the court house crying when I saw the picture there was no tears in that womans eyes and why was she with her husband if she was wanting a order of protection, and i couldnt under stand why her husband was crying he had got what he wanted so something just dont sound wright to me and someone got mad because the didnt get what they wanted sounds like my 12 year old and I think the judge should of told her to take her children back to her country with her we have enought illegals giving birth here so they can stray in the US if she dont fill safe here and she is afrade for her children than take them bake to her country and raise them there.
[ Report Abuse ]
Posted by: Voice of Reason Location: U.S. on Sep 21, 2007 at 05:14 PM

Civil Judges DO NOT provide court reporters. This is the responsibility of the individual parties or their attorneys. Calling Judge Young a "blithering idiot" based upon your inaccurate view of civil procedure is ridiculous. Further, Judge Young cannot respond or defend himself against these accusations as the case is still pending. How about waiting for all of the facts of what has been a one sided media blitz before forming an opinion?
[ Report Abuse ]
Posted by: Chris Location: home on Sep 15, 2007 at 06:01 AM

The judge should not have voiced his opinion. This was not a matter of law and her legal status as an immigrant. We have too many activist judges and have to live with their sometimes outrageous outcomes.
[ Report Abuse ]
Currently
Local Radar
Radar