Home ·  Contact Us ·  Classifieds ·  MyVLT2 ·  VolTV2Go ·  Volzeye ·  Desktop Alert
Home▼
Weather▼
News▼
Sports▼
Business▼
Lifestyle▼
Directories▼
Entertainment▼
Opinion▼
Inside▼
Man on trial in slaying of ex-wife's student lover Save Email Print
Posted: 9:13 AM Sep 5, 2008
Last Updated: 5:51 PM Sep 5, 2008

A | A | A

UPDATED 9/5/08 6:28 p.m.: KNOXVILLE, Tenn. (WVLT) -- The so-called love-triangle murder trial may come down to how jurors answer one question. Was Eric McLean a jealous husband or a frightened father on the night he shot and killed 18-year-old Sean Powell?

Eric McLean’s attorney has been saying all along that the key to the case is what happened during the seven minutes between the time his client called 911 to report that Powell would not leave his home and a second 911 call from Erin McLean saying Powell was dead.

Now, jurors have heard the calls for themselves.

Eric McLean listened in court as prosecutors play tapes of two 911 calls made on the deadly night.

On the 911 tape, Erin Mclean says, "My husband just killed someone.”

A dispatcher says, "How did he do it."

Erin McLean says, "He shot him in the head, with a shotgun."

That was not the first call from the McLean home to 911 on the night Sean Powell was killed. Seven minutes earlier, Eric McLean called 911 himself saying Powell was trespassing in his home. How did the situation turn so violent so quickly? McLean's attorney, Bruce Poston, says it's because Powell convinced McLean thought he was about to lose his two young sons to the young man who was already having an affair with his wife.

Eric McLean’s attorney Bruce Poston told the court, "He hears someone look at him and say 'in two weeks, they'll be calling me daddy'". "

Poston says Powell spoke those words while sitting in a car as McLean stood nearby armed with a rifle, begging him not to take the kids away. He says Erin McLean had just said some cruel words to her husband too.

Poston says, “She just said 'you are so week. Sean's ten times the man you are and I don't want my boys around someone like you. He's much better for them.'"

Police officers testify that Erin McLean sounded different minutes later when Powell lay dead in a car outside her house, going from shocked and yelling “Oh my God," to angry and saying, “I can't believe that he just killed him."

The defense hopes jurors will eventually see this was a crime of passion, manslaughter at worst. The prosecution says McLean is guilty of premeditated murder, a jealous man but not one who was suddenly shocked to discover his wife's affair.

Assistant District Attorney General Bill Crabtree says, "They agreed that they could see other people, so relationship between Sean Powell and Erin McLean was no secret to Eric McLean."

Since the jury is sequestered in a hotel anyway, they've decided to do some work this weekend.

Testimony will continue Saturday afternoon and again on Sunday.

You can keep up with the trial on Volunteer TV News and VolunteerTV.com where you can find a live Web stream whenever court is in session.

-----

UPDATED 9/5/08 2:50 p.m.: KNOXVILLE, Tenn. (AP) -- A school teacher's husband charged with murder in the fatal shooting of his wife's teenage student lover was either a calculated killer moved by jealousy or the victim of a spouse who flaunted her infidelity.

Lawyers made those arguments Friday in Knoxville to open the murder trial of 33-year-old Eric McLean.

McLean is charged with first-degree murder in last year's death of 18-year-old Sean Powell, the student who fell in love with McLean's wife. Erin McLean was a 29-year-old student-teacher at the time.

McLean has acknowledged shooting Powell, but claims it was an accident.

(Copyright 2008 by The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved.)

-----

KNOXVILLE, Tenn. (WVLT) -- Eric McLean's love-triangle murder trial is underway after two days of jury selection in a downtown Knoxville courtroom.

Eric McLean has admitted to killing Sean Powell, 18. Powell is believed to have been the teenage love of Erin McLean, Eric's wife and Sean Powell's student-teacher at West High School.

Eric McLean is charged with first degree murder, but his attorney says the charges should be manslaughter.

Volunteer TV court reporter Rob Pratt is in the courtroom, and the entire trial is being streamed live on VolunteerTV.com. Just CLICK HERE for the Web stream.

Click Pictures to Enlarge
More Stories
"The Santa Train" makes its rounds in Kentucky, Tennessee and Virginia

2nd Annual Cross Knox 15K races money for Knoxville's scenic Greenways

KARM assembles 1,300 Thanksgiving baskets for Knoxville families in need

Calhoun paper plant to have week of downtime

Nissan says buyout program met goals

Police respond to overnight quadruple shooting

East Tenn. aglow over nuclear growth

Lobbying efforts cost up to $65M in Tennessee

Post Your Comments
First Name:
Location:
Enter Comments: characters left
Email (optional):
Email will not be displayed on site. For station contact purpose only.
Read Comments
Comments are posted from viewers like you and do not always reflect the views of this station.
Posted by: cindy Location: lexington on Sep 10, 2008 at 01:40 PM
i do not belive that he meant to do it. i also think like the family of the 18 years. she should be held responsible for somethings. she knew better.that to get involved with an 18 year school student. that is awful. she is getting away with everything just to do it again at another school. please have some accountablity for what she has done to their son. not just him.

Posted by: Jimmy Location: Knoxville on Sep 9, 2008 at 08:56 AM
Is either lawyer going to call Erin to the stand? I would love to see her put under tremendous pressure by Eric's lawyer especially. She started all of this and I have watched this case on tv, computer, etc. and feel Eric should not get 1st degree murder and a sentence of 51 years. I think he should be punished but more like 2nd degree or man slaughter and more like 5 years in prison.

Posted by: rickdew Location: 3rd creek trail on Sep 9, 2008 at 07:58 AM
I think Erin was a confused woman herself and wanted out of her marraige. She is constantly drug through the mud with no voice. The court system awarded her custody and put Eric on trial for murder.

Posted by: Jack Location: PA on Sep 9, 2008 at 07:27 AM
What do you mean let Eric go? He murdered a man. Eric had already called 911. He obviously had a gun. Why didn't he hold Sean Powell at gun point until the police arrived? And if he felt he had to shoot an unarmed man in self-defense, why didn't he shoot him in his arm or leg instead of in the head? There is no way that he should walk. The situation did not justify murder.

Posted by: Jane Location: new market, Tn on Sep 8, 2008 at 12:56 PM
from what I have read, Erin tryed to seduce another teen in Nashville at a school where still was employed. Why wasn't she arrested for this? We could easily have another Shawn Powell to bury. Erin needs to own up to her part in Shawns untimely death. The Lawyer for Eric could have Erin forceably returned to Knoxville. So, why hasn't he done this? Eric did wrong in killing this boy , but a person can only be pushed just so far. A desperate man will do desperate things. we all will have to answer for our wrong doings in the end. God will be our final judge.

Posted by: Mark Location: Knoxville on Sep 6, 2008 at 08:06 PM
I would love to see charges pressed against Erin. She needs to be the one behind bars. Let Eric go and give him those kids. He has been through enough. It's bad enough that he has to live with this for the rest of his life.

Posted by: Mike D EANGELO Location: PA on Sep 6, 2008 at 08:01 PM
I REALLY FEEL FOR EVERY ONE IN THIS TRAGITY!except for eric-- i know now you are wondering why not eric !!!i do not feel after seeing all this testimony that you honestly have to feel for eric he is a strong father husband and human being that made the mistake of not firing the weapon on the right gender everybody could make a mistake and i know he did!!!I just hope ERIN takes enough pills next time to end her pathetic life that she has souly brought amonsked herself!SO THAT ERIC AND HIS FAMILY CAN LIVE IN PEACE AND LOVE!(that is all he worked for and has given his vows for in the first place!)

Posted by: Anonymous on Sep 6, 2008 at 10:31 AM
I think Erin needs to be charged also. She had no right to be with a student, no matter what age he was. She was the teacher. There is no telling what lies she told this boy. He was still in school so he had the mind of a kid and can be easily persuaded. I feel sorry that he lost his life but he should not have been going to her house. I feel like Eric should get his children back from his psyco wife. The news has already said she was with another student awhile back at a different school. Eric did wrong by killing Sean but he was probably scared and furious. There is no telling what Sean said to Eric before the shooting to set him off. I feel sorry for all of them. If Erin had not cheated none of this would have happened.

Posted by: Dan Location: Knoxville on Sep 6, 2008 at 10:18 AM
I have been Eric McLeans neighbor for over 10 years.I have seen him walk his sons to & from school ever since they stared at Bell Morris. No matter the weather he was there.I have spoke to him many times over the years and found him to be a very good person,caring father and a good neighbor.As for Erin his wife I rarely ever talked to her and she seemed to want to avoid speaking to you.I still can not believe that Eric could even be pushed to do what he did. But I guess I would snap too if I was told that my wife was leaving and that my sons would be better off with the other man and then to have him say that in 2 weeks they would be calling him daddy.What devoted father wouldn't snap? I"m sorry for Shawn Powells family. But he schould have realized what would happen by going to a married mans house and expecting to leave with his wife and kids. And then to expect there not to be any consequences? How wrapped around her little finger did she have him?

Posted by: Donna Location: Knoxville,TN on Sep 6, 2008 at 07:33 AM
Erin Mclean head no business cheating on her husband, and that young powell boy had no reason to dye either. Eric Powell should have got his kids and left that night. Instead of taking things in his own hands.

Posted by: Anonymous on Sep 5, 2008 at 10:30 PM
The only crime Eric Mclean committed was not shooting his "wife" when he shot her boyfriend. Powell got what he deserved & hopefully his piece of trash wife gets the same.

Posted by: Buford Location: knoxville on Sep 5, 2008 at 06:46 PM
When I look at that young man, I have nothing but pity for him. He will have to pay a debt to society but to deal with what he had to deal with is hard for me to comprehend. I have not seen any photos of the victim, but at his age, it is hard for me to imagine being seduced by a person in authority as he was. A truly sad story. The jury will need the wisdom of Solomon.

Posted by: Anonymous on Sep 5, 2008 at 02:25 PM
He has been through enough. The kid got what he deserveded. Now it's time his wife gets what she deserves.

VolunteerTV.com Most Discussed