New pap smear guidelines
Save Email Print
Bookmark and Share
Updated: 6:09 PM Nov 20, 2009
New pap smear guidelines
On the heels of a mammography controversy, new recommendations are out regarding cervical cancer screenings. The guidelines suggest women wait until their 20's to have their first pap smear and they can be rescreened less often than previously recommended. We talked with local doctors about what you should do.
Posted: 6:06 PM Nov 20, 2009
Reporter: Allison Kropff
Email Address: allison.kropff@wvlt-tv.com
width:200 and height: 150 and picwidth: 200 and pciheight: 150
Font Size:

KNOXVILLE, Tenn. (WVLT) - On the heels of a mammography controversy, new recommendations are out regarding cervical cancer screenings.

The guidelines suggest women wait until their 20's to have their first pap smear and they can be rescreened less often than previously recommended.

We talked with local doctors about what you should do.

It's another significant change in the way to screen cancer. New guidelines suggest women should begin getting pap smears at 21, instead of three years after they become sexually active as previously recommended. Exams should then continue every other year.

"Prior to the 1980s, there wasn't good science to dictate how often women should get Pap tests. Since then, we know more about the disease," says Alan G. Waxman with the ACOG Committee on Practice.

The American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, or ACOG, who released the guidelines, also say women 30 and older should wait three years between paps once they have had three consecutive clear tests.

"I just have a hard time with those guidelines because in our line of work we don't really deal with the abstractions such as percentages."

Dr. Ellen Moffat, an ob/gyn with Ft. Sanders Hospital has had several young patients fight, and die, from cervical cancer.

"When you experience that whether you're a physician or a loved one, these guidelines kind of go out the window," says Moffat.

"There's no evidence whatsoever these cervical cancer guidelines will lead to any increased deaths," says Dr. Bernadine Healy, a health editor with US News & World Report.

To avoid confusion, Dr. Moffat says to talk with your doctor.

She says she'll continue to recommend to her patients annual exams and pap smears when a woman becomes sexually active. "I always look at the risk/benefit ratio, it's not that bad to get a pelvic exam and the benefits of finding something abnormal at an early stage greatly outweighs the risk of doing an exam."

Dr. Moffat recommends annual exams until age 75, unless the patient has had a hysterectomy or other procedures. Another reason she says it's important to talk with your doctor.


Latest Comments

Posted by: Lin Location: Friendsville on Nov 24, 2009 at 05:11 PM

Got to love the changes that are coming out of medical care for everyone. Oops still not everyone has anyone notice that. I just want to know when these experts come up with changes to male prostrate check-ups. Guess we don't need early detection there either.
Posted by: DAVID Location: MAYNARDVILLE on Nov 21, 2009 at 03:53 PM

LOOKS TO ME ITS JUST ANOTHER PART OF OBAMACARE WHY DON'T THEY FIX THE PROBLEMS WITH OUR HEALTH CARE INSTEAD OF TRYING TO GIVE THE GOVERNMENT COMPLETE CONTROL
Posted by: Ms. P Location: Tennessee on Nov 21, 2009 at 07:28 AM

Early detection of cancer is one of the most powerful man-made tools we have at present. Pap smears not only detect cancer, but, STDs as well. How much more are we the people going to tolerate. Are we going to continually allow others (government, insurance companies) to determine whether we stay live or die?

Local Events

Loading…
Events by eviesays.com
Stock Indexes
  • .DJI
  • 12801.23
  • -89.23
  • -0.69%
  • .INX
  • 1342.64
  • -9.31
  • -0.69%
  • .IXIC
  • 2903.88
  • -23.35
  • -0.80%
  • NYA
  • 7992.03
  • -89.22
  • -1.10%
Enter Ticker Symbal to get quote:
Quotes updated every 15 minutes
Stock Quotes